
Tangled up in ecru
For the second successive away trip in the league, Town self-immolated in bizarre fashion, handing their hosts a deserved, but not particularly hard-earned, victory.
The majority of the blame, rightly, will rest with loanee keeper Goodman, who never recovered from a shaky start to proceedings which, ironically, began with a fine double save (though the follow-up he prevented would have been ruled offside), but soon descended into Tim Clark-levels of clownishness.
Underlying the frailty between the sticks, however, was a curious approach to a Yorkshire derby: intricate, terror-inducing play across the back that always looked liable to collapse.
Meticulous planning, theoretical strategies and drilled coaching can easily crumble in the intensity of a derby, and the over-playing merely acted as a trigger for a relentless and effective Barnsley press, who clearly understood that you have to earn the right to be fancy-Dan.
The huge and loud away support watched on with an anxiety which must have been felt by players whose confidence in the tactics looked, if not shaky, then at least on edge. Mistakes crept in early, with a Roughan slip leading to danger and several attempts to get up the pitch strangled at birth in the middle of the park.
Barnsley dominated the crucial early stages and were gifted an opener when Goodman spilled a routine cross to Keillor-Dunn’s feet before ten minutes were up.
The error clearly preyed on the young keeper’s mind and he looked decidedly uncomfortable from that point, including nearly carrying the ball out of his area when he came out to meet a long through ball. Only a linesman’s generous interpretation prevented further trouble for Goodman.
Sadly, the warning wasn’t heeded and his next impetuous gallivant to deal with a situation in which he should have had no part completely derailed his team.
A ball down the line lifted over Feeney, who was covering for an advanced Gooch, towards McGoldrick was mildly threatening but heading towards the corner rather than directly on goal. Goodman took it upon himself to summon his inner Harald Schumacher and assault Barnsley’s veteran striker.
A red card was inevitable and, just as Town are incapable of taking advantage of playing against ten men, examples of heroics when similarly denuded are very rare.
The omens surrounding Town’s trip to Oakwell, a destination of decidedly mixed fortunes, had not been helped by the club deciding to cock a snook at the football gods by debuting the second iteration of an ecru kit.
The first, as supporters of a certain vintage will recall, was donned by a Peter Jackson XI who were 6-0 down on a bleak Friday night at half-time, eventually conceding seven. Thankfully, the yellow-and-black checkerboard kit won’t be brought back for the visit of Manchester City.
Before the sending-off, Town had settled down to an extent and Wiles should have levelled when one-on-one with the keeper, having been found by Harness with an excellent ball. Lacking composure, his effort was reasonably easily saved.
More frustratingly, however, Town regularly found Roosken in space on the left only for the Dutchman to waste several very promising attacks. A reassessment of his efficacy as a winger is now long overdue — a fit Miller, or a new recruit, would have exploited those opportunities far more clinically.
This is not to suggest, in any way, that Town were ever on top. Barnsley’s rearguard solidly dealt with any attacking ambition of their rivals.
Nicholls replaced the wretched Goodman and could now reclaim his number-one position in his rival’s enforced absence, but he could do nothing to prevent Barnsley doubling their lead just before the break, effectively settling the contest.
If there was a hefty slice of good fortune in a strike from the edge of the area heavily deflecting off Roughan following a corner-clearing header, leaving Connell unmarked and then failing to get out quickly enough to him contributed to Town’s undoing.
A disastrous first half, then, and one which had only been seconds old when May went down with an injury which looked serious and took some time to resolve. He played on but was replaced at half-time by Taylor, hopefully as a precaution.
A dour and forgettable second half saw Town put in a decent effort with depleted numbers but they rarely looked like scoring to put some doubt in the minds of their hosts.
The efforts were acknowledged by a loud away end who did their best to raise the ten men, but Barnsley quelled the attempts with some comfort. They were helped, however, by a sub-par second-half performance from the referee, who missed several home infringements, including a clear pull-back on Taylor and a bizarre interpretation of a foul on Sorensen where he punished the Dane.
His ineptitude was not the reason for Town’s demise, as the damage had already been done, but it was a little cruel for them to fall further behind late on when Nicholls parried a shot to the feet of the blessed Keillor-Dunn, who bagged surely the easiest brace of his career.
A late Taylor consolation, latching on to a loose back-pass, gave the defeat a more respectable hue but couldn’t erase the pain of a day that needs to be resigned to history very quickly.
Grant will no doubt take stock, learn lessons and reassert his faith in “the group”, as he should, but sometimes the basics can be lost amidst the theories — and earning the right to play, which may be a cliché but is true for a reason, should be the first thing drilled home.
The supporters have clearly not lost faith in the promise of this season given the noise they made unwaveringly, but there cannot be a repeat of this in the next Yorkshire derby in two weeks’ time.






